Income Protection Insurance vs Life Insurance Policy in New Zealand
TL;DR
- What they pay and when: A life insurance policy pays a lump sum on death or terminal illness; income protection insurance pays a monthly benefit when you can’t work due to illness or injury. This is the core difference between income protection insurance and a life insurance policy.
- Tax (individuals): Life-policy lump sums are generally not taxable income; income protection insurance benefits are typically taxable, and premiums can be deductible only when the benefit would be taxable (see Inland Revenue guidance on Non-business expenses and the IR3G 2025 guide). Inland Revenue
- ACC doesn’t cover most illnesses: ACC supports accident/injury events, not general illness—hence the role of income protection insurance (see ACC’s Injuries we cover and Injuries we don’t cover). ACC
- Who’s allowed to operate: Underwriters must appear on the Reserve Bank of New Zealand Register of Licensed Insurers; advice must be given by, or under, an FMA-licensed Financial Advice Provider (FAP). rbnz.govt.nz
Find the right New Zealand insurance providers for your situation — Compare Now! .
What each one does (and doesn’t) — New Zealand context
Income protection insurance
- Pays a monthly benefit when illness or injury stops you from working.
- You choose settings like waiting period (how long you self-fund before payments start) and benefit period (how long payments continue).
- Payments can be reduced by other income (e.g., employer payments or ACC) depending on the policy wording.
- For the fundamentals, see What is Income Protection Insurance?
Life insurance policy
- Pays a lump sum if you die or are diagnosed as terminally ill (as defined in the policy).
- Common uses: clear a mortgage or debts, and provide financial support for your family.
- It does not replace monthly income during a long illness or recovery period.
Why this matters
Understanding income protection insurance vs life insurance policy starts with the event that triggers payment and how the money arrives—monthly income replacement versus a one-off lump sum.
Triggers & payout mechanics (side-by-side)
Income protection insurance — how it pays
- Trigger: You’re unable to work due to illness or injury and you’ve served the waiting period stated in the policy.
- Payout form: A monthly benefit is paid for the benefit period you selected (e.g., 2 years, 5 years, or to age 65).
- Important mechanics: Payments can be offset by other income you receive (e.g., employer payments or ACC), and claims must meet the policy’s disability definition (such as “own occupation” or “duties-based” tests).
Life insurance policy — how it pays
- Trigger: Death or diagnosis of terminal illness (as defined in the policy).
- Payout form: A single lump sum to your estate or nominated beneficiary(ies).
- Important mechanics: The lump sum isn’t tied to your ability to work and isn’t reduced by other income sources.
Why this matters
When comparing income protection insurance vs life insurance policy, the payout structure—monthly income replacement vs lump-sum—is the core difference that drives how households actually use the money.
Curious how changing the waiting period or benefit period affects price and protection? Compare now
Tax in plain NZ English (why it changes the choice)
Life insurance policy (personal cover)
- The lump-sum a beneficiary receives is generally not treated as taxable income.
- Premiums you pay personally are normally not tax-deductible.
- Takeaway: suits significant one-off needs (mortgage, family support) without ongoing tax implications on the payout.
Income protection insurance
- The monthly benefit is usually taxable because it replaces your income.
- Premiums may be deductible when the benefit would be taxable (depends on your policy structure and personal circumstances).
- Takeaway: compare after-tax benefit (what lands in your account) rather than just the headline amount.
Why this matters
Tax outcomes differ in income protection insurance vs life insurance policy, which affects the net value you and your household actually receive. (KW5/8)
Want the short version on deductibility?
See our step-by-step explainer: Income Protection Insurance Tax Deduction — 2025 Guide .
ACC vs income protection insurance (the illness gap)
What ACC does (in plain language)
- ACC is designed for accidents and injuries. If you’re hurt in an accident, ACC may help with treatment and a portion of lost earnings.
- It doesn’t cover most illnesses (e.g., cancer, chronic conditions, many mental-health-related incapacity scenarios without an accident).
Where income protection insurance fits
- Income protection insurance is designed to pay a monthly benefit during illness or injury that prevents you from working, after your chosen waiting period.
- It can bridge the cash flow gap when ACC doesn’t apply (illness) or when ACC income support isn’t enough for your actual expenses.
Why this matters
Many Kiwis only see the real-world difference in income protection insurance vs life insurance policy when a long illness stops their income but doesn’t trigger ACC support.
Want a detailed walk-through of what ACC covers (and doesn’t) and how income protection insurance plugs the gap?
Read: ACC vs Income Protection Insurance in New Zealand.
Price drivers you control
Income protection insurance — levers that move the premium
- Percentage of income insured: A higher monthly benefit costs more; many Kiwis insure just enough to cover essentials (mortgage, utilities, groceries) rather than their full take-home.
- Waiting period: Longer waits (e.g., 8–13 weeks) usually lower premiums; shorter waits (e.g., 2–4 weeks) cost more but start paying sooner.
- Benefit period: A cover to age 65 costs more than a 2–5-year benefit period; the longer the potential payout window, the higher the price.
- Occupation class: Roles with manual/physical risk generally price higher than desk-based work.
- Policy structure and offsets: Definitions of disability, partial benefits, and how other income (employer payments or ACC) is treated can influence both price and what you actually receive at claim time.
- Age, health, smoker status, and loadings: Older age or certain medical histories can increase premiums; quitting smoking can materially reduce costs over time.
Life insurance policy — levers that move the premium
- Sum insured: Larger lump sums (e.g., to clear a whole mortgage plus family support) cost more.
- Age and health: Premiums rise with age; favourable underwriting (good health, non-smoker) helps.
- Term and options: Level vs stepped premiums, and any optional add-ons, change the curve of cost over time.
- Lifestyle factors: Smoking and some high-risk activities can trigger loadings.
Why this matters
Price levers in income protection insurance vs. life insurance policies work differently: one tunes monthly cash flow support via waiting/benefit periods; the other sets a single lump-sum target. Getting these settings right is the difference between an affordable premium and cover that actually fits when you need it.
Who each suits (scenarios focused on the difference)
Single, no dependants
- Priority often lies with income protection insurance because your biggest risk is losing monthly income due to illness or injury.
- A small life insurance policy might still be helpful for funeral costs or small debts.
Mortgage + dependants
- A life insurance policy sets up a lump sum to clear the mortgage and protect whānau.
- Income protection insurance keeps cash flow going for everyday bills while you recover.
Self-employed or contractor
- With no employer sick leave and illness usually outside ACC, income protection insurance is often essential for ongoing living costs.
- Some still hold a life insurance policy to protect business debts or family needs.
Near retirement with low debt
- A reduced life insurance policy may cover final expenses or specific gifts.
- Income protection insurance can still matter if you rely on work income for a few more years—choose waiting/benefit periods carefully.
Why this matters
Your mix in income protection insurance vs life insurance policy depends on who relies on your income, your debts, and how long you need cover to last.
How to verify providers (short, NZ-specific)
Underwriters (insurers)
- Confirm the company is licensed to underwrite insurance in New Zealand. Look up the legal entity name (not just the brand) on the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) Register of Licensed Insurers.
- Check for run-off or ownership changes that could affect service or policy wording updates.
Advice providers
- Make sure you’re dealing with a licensed Financial Advice Provider (FAP) or a nominated representative of one, with clear scope of advice (which products/insurers they can compare).
- Ask for their disclosure: fees/commissions, conflicts management, complaints process, and dispute resolution scheme.
Practical checklist
- Legal entity name matches what’s on your quote/application.
- Current New Zealand physical address and contact details.
- Access to policy wordings and product disclosure before you buy.
- A written needs analysis and rationale for recommendations (so you can revisit settings later).
- Clear claims support process: who helps you, how to notify, typical timeframes, and what documents are needed.
If you ever need to claim (why the difference matters then)
Life insurance policy — what to expect
- Trigger & evidence: Death certificate or a terminal-illness certification that meets the policy definition (e.g., life expectancy within the stated timeframe).
- Process: Notify the insurer or your adviser, submit forms and proof of identity/beneficiaries, and provide any medical records requested.
- Timeframes: Once the claim is accepted, payment is a single lump sum to the estate or nominated beneficiaries. Keep bank/solicitor details ready.
- Practical tips:
○ Make sure beneficiary nominations are current and match your wishes.
○ Keep a copy of the policy wording and schedule with your will/estate documents.
○ Tell your executor and a trusted family member where documents are kept.
Income protection insurance — what to expect
- Trigger & evidence: You’re unable to work due to illness or injury and have served the waiting period. Provide medical evidence (GP/specialist reports), employment/income verification (payslips, accounts if self-employed), and any ACC correspondence.
- Process:
○ Notify early (you can open a claim during the waiting period).
○ Submit the claim form plus medical and financial documents.
○ Participate in regular reviews (ongoing medical certificates, income updates).
- Payments: Made monthly for the benefit period you selected (e.g., 2 or 5 years, or to age 65).
- Offsets & partial benefits: If you receive income from ACC or an employer, the insurer may offset this under the policy wording. If you can return to work part-time or to some duties, you may qualify for partial/rehabilitation benefits.
- Practical tips:
○ Choose a waiting period that matches your sick leave/savings; document any employer payments.
○ Keep copies of all medical notes, invoices, and correspondence (including ACC).
○ Engage with rehab/return-to-work programmes offered — these can support faster recovery and help sustain payments.
○ If self-employed, keep financial records (P&L, GST returns) up to date to evidence pre-disability income.
Why this matters
- One product is built for a once-only payout; the other is an ongoing claim that can change with your recovery, work capacity, and other income. Planning for documents, reviews, and offsets up front makes claims smoother and reduces surprises.
FAQ
Q: What’s the core difference between income protection insurance and a life insurance policy?
A: Income protection insurance pays a monthly benefit when illness or injury stops you working (after a waiting period). A life insurance policy pays a lump sum on death or terminal illness.
Q: Does income protection insurance cover mental-health-related inability to work?
A: Often yes, provided you meet the policy’s disability definition and waiting period. Some policies have specific terms, limits, or exclusions—always check the wording.
Q: Are income protection insurance benefits taxable in New Zealand?
A: Generally, yes, because they replace income. Insurers pay benefits before or after tax, depending on the structure; your net position depends on your marginal tax rate.
Q: Are life insurance policy payouts taxable in New Zealand?
A: For personal policies, the lump sum is generally not treated as taxable income.
Q: Does ACC replace the need for income protection insurance?
A: No. ACC focuses on accidents/injuries. Most illness isn’t covered, which is where income protection insurance can help.
Q: How much of my income can I insure with income protection insurance?
A: Policies typically allow up to a percentage of pre-disability income (subject to caps and proof). The aim is to maintain essential expenses rather than your full take-home.
Q: What waiting period and benefit period should I choose for income protection insurance?
A: Match the waiting period to your sick leave/savings; choose a benefit period based on how long you’d need support (e.g., 2–5 years or to age 65). More extended benefit periods cost more but offer greater resilience.
Q: Can I have both income protection insurance and a life insurance policy?
A: Yes. Many Kiwis combine them: life cover for debts/family support, income protection insurance for a monthly cash flow during illness or injury.
Q: Will payments from ACC or my employer reduce income protection insurance benefits?
A: They can. Most policies include offsets, which may reduce the insurer’s payment when you receive other income during a claim.
Q: How do I check that an insurer or adviser is appropriately licensed in New Zealand?
A: Confirm the underwriter on the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) Register of Licensed Insurers, and the advice provider under the FMA Financial Advice Provider (FAP) regime.
Wrap-up (plain, action-focused)
- Different jobs, different payouts: One product is designed to replace monthly income during illness or injury, the other to provide a single lump sum on death or terminal illness.
- Set the dials that matter: For monthly cover, the big levers are waiting period, benefit period, and how other income is treated under the policy. For lump-sum cover, it’s the sum insured and your personal risk factors.
- Choose by need, not label: Map your debts, dependants, and cash flow needs, then decide the mix and levels that fit.
- Keep documents tidy: Store policies, beneficiary details, and any claims notes together, and tell your executor/a trusted family member where they are.
Conclusion
Choosing between a monthly income replacement during illness or injury and a lump-sum for death or terminal illness isn’t about picking a winner — it’s about matching cover to the real risks you face. If your family depends on your income, income protection insurance helps keep the bills paid while you recover. If you’ve got a mortgage or want to leave a financial cushion, a life insurance policy delivers certainty in one payment. Most Kiwis land on a mix that fits their debts, dependants, and savings buffer — then tune the waiting and benefit periods (for income protection insurance) and the sum insured (for life insurance) so the cover remains affordable and reliable.
Ready to see which settings work for you? Compare now
